PLYMOUTH, Mass. — Three jurors from Lindsay Clancy’s murder trial — including the foreperson — spoke publicly Tuesday, Sept. 8, 2026, saying a lone male holdout admitted he had reasonable doubt about the Commonwealth’s case and still refused to join an acquittal by reason of lack of criminal responsibility.

The exclusive interview with NBC10 Boston’s Sue O’Connell came days after Judge William Sullivan declared a mistrial Friday when the nine-woman, three-man panel deadlocked after roughly a week of deliberations. Jurors who identified themselves on air included Paula Devlin, Roni Carlson, and Kellie Farina. NewsNation, Fox News, and other outlets relayed the same central quotes from the NBC10 package.

“He admitted he had reasonable doubt and I started filling out the forms, I was so excited,” the foreperson told NBC10 Boston. She said the holdout then added, “But I’m still not going to say that she’s not guilty by reason of insanity.”

That account matches what defense attorney Kevin Reddington argued in open court and outside the courthouse after the mistrial: that 11 jurors were prepared to acquit on lack of criminal responsibility and one man blocked a unanimous verdict. The foreperson also said she was the author of the note to the judge flagging a juror who expressed reasonable doubt but would not agree to a verdict — the clash that produced private questioning of jurors and a heated exchange between Reddington and Sullivan before the mistrial.

Clancy, 36, a former labor-and-delivery nurse, faces Massachusetts first-degree murder charges for strangling her three children in Duxbury in January 2023. The defense argued postpartum psychosis and overmedication; prosecutors said she planned the killings and knew right from wrong. Verdict options also included second-degree murder and manslaughter. After the slayings she cut herself, jumped from a second-story window, and now uses a wheelchair.

NBC10 said it tried to reach the juror described as the holdout and had not received a response. The three jurors said deliberations grew so heated that alternates could hear them — and that they remained determined to reach a verdict until the panel told the court it could not.

Plymouth County District Attorney Tim Cruz still has not announced whether his office will seek a retrial. A status hearing is set for Sept. 29. Reddington has separately floated plea talks and, on Good Morning America Tuesday morning, a presidential pardon that Article II does not authorize for state crimes — as Insanity Developing reported earlier today.

Sources